| |
Peripheral neuropathy (persists) in HIV: prevalence and risk factors
|
| |
| |
AIDS:
24 April 2011
Evans, Scott Ra; Ellis, Ronald Jb; Chen, Huichaoa; Yeh, Tzu-mina; Lee, Anthony Ja; Schifitto, Giovannic; Wu, Kunlinga; Bosch, Ronald Ja; McArthur, Justin Cd; Simpson, David Me; Clifford, David Bf
aHarvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
bUniversity of California at San Diego, San Diego, California, USA
cUniversity of Rochester, Rochester, New York, USA
dJohns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
eMount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, New York, USA
fWashington University, Saint Louis, Missouri, USA.
"Damage to peripheral nerves may be insidious but the persistence of dysfunction once nerves are damaged suggests that it is important to acknowledge this developing toxicity and to seek means of minimizing it........Our observations suggest that in treatment-naïve HIV patients receiving state of the ART therapy, peripheral neuropathy is found in more than 30%, whereas about a third of that number will also have symptoms.......Given the rapidly aging HIV population due to successful therapy, the intersection of aging and increased risk of neuropathy portends ongoing challenges from this complication for HIV therapeutics......Nadir CD4, in this treatment-naive cohort represented by the baseline CD4, also is associated with greater risk of peripheral neuropathy (but not SPN).....Validation of our observations is found with confirmation that nART increases the risk of neuropathy. This is an important reason that alternatives to nART should be made available to HIV patients worldwide......our data suggest that diabetes is capable of substantially raising the risk of SPN. This is a very serious finding given the increasing impact of insulin resistance and diabetes in the setting of HIV infection.(dah).......Ongoing studies have shown an association between triglycerides and sensory neuropathy. Individuals taking statins are more likely to have elevated triglyceride levels, potentially mediating the association between statins and neuropathy in HIV [27]......Patients that had peripheral neuropathy (and SPN) while on nART and later withdrew nART were followed to evaluate recovery. A 54.1% (44.8%, 63.2%) of patients continued to have peripheral neuropathy during all remaining follow-up, whereas 18% (11.7%, 26.0%) of patients had no peripheral neuropathy during all remaining follow-up. 36.8% (24.5%, 50.7%) of patients continued to have SPN during all remaining follow-up, whereas 43.9% (30.7%, 57.6%) of patients had no SPN during all remaining follow-up."
"Cognitive Impairment & Neuropathy Persist Despite HAART and Are Associated With Metabolic Syndrome"
Cognitive Impairment & Neuropathy Persist Despite HAART and Are ...
Feb 20, 2009 ... Cognitive Impairment & Neuropathy Persist Despite HAART and Are Associated With Metabolic Syndrome. Reported by Jules Levin ...
www.natap.org/2009/CROI/croi_111.htm
HIV-Associated Peripheral Neuropathy in the HAART Era: Results ...
But you can get the general sense from the lines in the graph that neuropathy persists over time. Prevalence Signs and symptoms of PN persist despite viral ...
www.natap.org/2009/CROI/croi_118.htm
Abstract
Objectives: To estimate neuropathic sign/symptom rates with initiation of combination antiretroviral therapy (cART) in HIV-infected ART-naive patients, and to investigate risk factors for: peripheral neuropathy and symptomatic peripheral neuropathy (SPN), recovery from peripheral neuropathy/SPN after neurotoxic ART (nART) discontinuation, and the absence of peripheral neuropathy/SPN while on nART.
Design: AIDS Clinical Trials Group (ACTG) Longitudinal Linked Randomized Trial participants who initiated cART in randomized trials for ART-naive patients were annually screened for symptoms/signs of peripheral neuropathy. ART use and disease characteristics were collected longitudinally.
Methods: Peripheral neuropathy was defined as at least mild loss of vibration sensation in both great toes or absent/hypoactive ankle reflexes bilaterally. SPN was defined as peripheral neuropathy and bilateral symptoms. Generalized estimating equation logistic regression was used to estimate associations.
Results: Two thousand, one hundred and forty-one participants were followed from January 2000 to June 2007. Rates of peripheral neuropathy/SPN at 3 years were 32.1/8.6% despite 87.1% with HIV-1RNA 400 copies/ml or less and 70.3% with CD4 greater than 350 cells/μl. Associations with higher odds of peripheral neuropathy included older patient age and current nART use. Associations with higher odds of SPN included older patient age, nART use, and history of diabetes mellitus. Associations with lower odds of recovery after nART discontinuation included older patient age. Associations with higher odds of peripheral neuropathy while on nART included older patient age and current protease inhibitor use. Associations with higher odds of SPN while on nART included older patient age, history of diabetes, taller height, and protease inhibitor use.
Conclusion: Signs of peripheral neuropathy remain despite virologic/immunologic control but frequently occurs without symptoms. Aging is a risk factor for peripheral neuropathy/SPN.
Introduction
Combination antiretroviral (cART) therapy has resulted in declines in the incidences of HIV-associated dementia and central nervous system (CNS) opportunistic infections. However, sensory neuropathies are still prevalent as the most frequent neurological disorder associated with HIV infection and its treatment with ART [1-3]. Ellis et al. [4] reports that distal sensory polyneuropathy is prevalent (57%) in the cART era.
There are two major types of HIV-associated distal sensory peripheral neuropathies: primary HIV-associated distal sensory polyneuropathy (HIV-DSP) and ART toxic neuropathy (ATN), together which affect approximately 30-67% of patients with advanced HIV disease [5,6]. HIV-DSP is the most common sensory neuropathy in HIV infection with a reported 1-year incidence in an advanced patient cohort selected for neurologic disease risk of 36/21% in the pre-cART/cART eras, respectively [7]. ATN is associated with neurotoxic ART (nART), for example, dideoxynucleoside analogs and shares most clinical features of HIV-DSP except that neuropathy develops while taking the nART. ATN is the most common toxicity of ART therapy in sub-Saharan Africa [5,6,8-10].
The pathology of HIV-DSP involves a length-dependent degeneration of both small and large peripheral nerve fibers but the pathogenesis is unknown [6,11,12]. The pathogenesis of ATN is believed to reflect inhibition of gamma DNA polymerase by nARTs leading to reduced mitochondrial DNA content and therefore to mitochondrial dysfunction [13]. Reduced mitochondrial DNA levels in subcutaneous fat obtained by punch skin biopsies have been associated with ATN [14,15].
The signs/symptoms of HIV-DSP and ATN resemble common neuropathies encountered in clinical practice including diabetic and alcohol-associated neuropathy. Symptoms include numbness, paresthesia, burning sensation, and stabbing pain. Common signs include reduced or absent ankle reflexes relative to patellar reflexes, reduced or absent vibration sensation in the toes, and decreased pin and temperature sensation in a stocking/glove distribution. No FDA-approved therapies exist for HIV-associated sensory neuropathies with treatment limited to symptomatic measures with limited efficacy [1].
Higher plasma HIV-1 RNA and lower CD4+ cell counts before the initiation of ART increased the risk of HIV-DSP in the pre-cART era [16,17]. Risk factors in the cART era have been investigated [7,18-23]. Data suggest that risk factors include prolonged exposure to cART [24], protease inhibitor exposure [25] and lipid-lowering drugs (statins and fibrates) [26]. Diabetes mellitus is a common cause of sensory neuropathy, and ART therapy, especially protease inhibitors, is associated with diabetes mellitus [27]. Ances et al. [28] reports that the risk for HIV-DSP is associated with diabetes and hypertriglyceridemia but not by other metabolic syndrome components. The interaction between metabolic syndrome and HIV is unclear. Height has been identified as a risk factor for peripheral neuropathy in diabetes [29] and recently in HIV infection when using nARTs [30].
We evaluated potential risk factors for peripheral neuropathy and symptomatic peripheral neuropathy (SPN) using data from more than 2000 ART-naive patients initiating cART in six randomized AIDS Clinical Trials Group (ACTG) trials.
Discussion
Peripheral neuropathy in HIV patients persists despite improved immunologic function and virologic control associated with cART and decreased nART use. Our data span studies in which nART was initiated to recent studies avoiding nART. nART use has become uncommon in the developed world yet remains in resource-limited settings due to low cost, making these observations relevant. Additionally, this study considers the impact of diabetes, statins, and protease inhibitors, all of which are central issues for HIV care.
Damage to peripheral nerves may be insidious but the persistence of dysfunction once nerves are damaged suggests that it is important to acknowledge this developing toxicity and to seek means of minimizing it. Evidence of peripheral nerve damage is easily detectable on an exam by trained non-neurologist staff as was done in this study. It is likely that the asymptomatic neuropathy patients will be more likely to become symptomatic when challenged with nART or other risks for peripheral neuropathy, if asymptomatic neuropathy is ignored. Our observations suggest that in treatment-naïve HIV patients receiving state of the ART therapy, peripheral neuropathy is found in more than 30%, whereas about a third of that number will also have symptoms. Sicker patients not enrolled in clinical trials, those with nutritional deficiency or more complications are likely at higher risk. However, diagnostic characteristics of our instrument [37,38] indicate that prevalence may be substantially lower. Using sensitivity/specificity estimates of 73/68% [37] derived from reference comparison to a neurologist total neuropathy score (TNS) evaluation, an observed prevalence of 40% from our study, suggests a prevalence of 20% had the TNS evaluation been performed.
Our findings support other observations about the importance of age to neuropathy in HIV [40,41]. Peripheral nerves are long, large, and metabolically stressed cells that are likely particularly vulnerable to toxicity and damage. Aging appears to increase this vulnerability making age one of the most notable and consistent risk factors for peripheral neuropathy. Given the rapidly aging HIV population due to successful therapy, the intersection of aging and increased risk of neuropathy portends ongoing challenges from this complication for HIV therapeutics.
Early studies emphasized CD4 and viral load as risk factors, but with successful therapy these associations have become less important. Specifically viral suppression did not decrease the odds of peripheral neuropathy or SPN. However, underlying HIV disease impacts the risk of neuropathy with evidence that successful HIV treatment as reflected by higher CD4 cell count is associated with a lower risk of neuropathy than found in those whose CD4 responses are poorer (Fig. 2a,b). Current CD4 200 cells/μl or less, reflecting advanced disease is a risk for peripheral neuropathy/SPN. Nadir CD4, in this treatment-naive cohort represented by the baseline CD4, also is associated with greater risk of peripheral neuropathy (but not SPN) [41]. In contrast, current viral load data failed to be associated with neuropathy outcomes.
Validation of our observations is found with confirmation that nART increases the risk of neuropathy. This is an important reason that alternatives to nART should be made available to HIV patients worldwide. A more subtle and uncertain area of ART neurotoxicity surrounds the status of protease inhibitors. Clinical and in-vitro studies have supported the possibility of protease inhibitor-associated neuropathy. Experienced clinicians have generally not recognized this association. The CHARTER study found only weak evidence for any of the protease inhibitor drugs contributing to neuropathy [41]. Our analyses do not support the claim that protease inhibitor use is associated with increased risk of neuropathy overall. However, our data do not fully exonerate protease inhibitor risk, as there appears an association of increased neuropathy risk with protease inhibitor used in conjunction with nART. Given the observational nature of the study, it may be that patients on nART and protease inhibitors vs. patients on nART without protease inhibitors are inherently different, potentially biasing the estimate of the protease inhibitor association. However, the protease inhibitor association was estimated while controlling for disease characteristics, demographics, and concomitant therapy. This will be critically important as second-line therapies are introduced in developing world sites where it may be common to pair nART with protease inhibitor in salvage regimens. Our data suggest that such combinations would be more likely to induce neuropathy.
Our data reinforce the interaction of glucose intolerance/diabetes with neuropathy risk. Many HIV neuropathy studies exclude diabetics so the degree of interaction of these problems has not been well described. Whereas the numbers of diabetic patients in our study is modest, our data suggest that diabetes is capable of substantially raising the risk of SPN. This is a very serious finding given the increasing impact of insulin resistance and diabetes in the setting of HIV infection.
Our study confirms the clinical impression that neuropathy in HIV is length-dependent, with a small, but consistently significant contribution in taller persons, which is consistent with a recent study [29] that associates patient height and risk of developing ATN in an international study. However, the impact of height is modest compared to aging and glucose intolerance. Hepatitis C is a frequent and serious coinfection of HIV patients, and the possibility that it influences neurological outcomes continues to be a concern. Our analyses support other observations about the lack of association of HCV coinfection with neuropathy [42].
Statin drugs are very widely used in the developed world and particularly in HIV populations with elevated cholesterols and enhanced cardiovascular risk. Statins have been implicated as causing neuropathy in other populations [43], although subsequent studies have not confirmed these findings. Our data suggest that this is an area in which more attention is needed in HIV therapeutics, since we found symptomatic neuropathy to be enhanced with concurrent statin use. However, statins did not seem to augment risk of neuropathy in patients on nART. Ongoing studies have shown an association between triglycerides and sensory neuropathy. Individuals taking statins are more likely to have elevated triglyceride levels, potentially mediating the association between statins and neuropathy in HIV [27].
Whereas there is considerable information confirming the risk of neuropathy with use of nART, traditionally reversal of neuropathy with discontinuation of nART was used to confirm the causative association of the drug for neuropathy. Clinical experience that some patients developing such neuropathy have recovery has not been carefully studied in large populations. We evaluated factors predicting recovery from neuropathy. The results show a strong influence with advancing age reducing the risk of recovery. It is also notable that statin use appears to decrease the chance of recovery from symptomatic neuropathy, a factor that could be of considerable clinical importance. Diabetes reflected by insulin use also predicts less chance for reversal of symptomatic neuropathy, suggesting that combining the diabetic risk with nART-induced mitochondrial deficits may be a particularly troublesome neurotoxic situation. HIV affects diverse populations worldwide. Racial disparity with regard to complications remains an intriguing and important area for thoughtful observations. African American (Black) patients in our cohort had increased risk of peripheral neuropathy which did not extend to SPN. The cause of this apparent risk is unknown, but higher risk of diabetes, hypertension, and potentially other genetic or pharmacokinetic risks could be considered.
Limitations of this study include its observational nature with the potential for informative drop-out/in, self-selection issues in ART and concomitant medication use, and that the observed association may not be causal. There is a potential for selection bias as the analyses are restricted to clinical trial volunteers that were willing and able to return for follow-up visits. Results could be biased if these patients are very different than patients not included in analyses. Estimated association with variables subject to self-selection should be interpreted with caution. Nonsignificant P values should not be interpreted as 'no association'. Instead the CIs should be used to 'rule out' associations with reasonable confidence. Some effect estimates, although not significant, cannot rule out potentially large associations.
Results
Demographics and baseline characteristics
Two thousand one hundred and forty-one ART-naïve participants (81% men, 44% white, 32% black, median age = 39 years, median log10 HIV-1 RNA = 4.90 copies/ml and median CD4 cell count = 206 cell/μl at cART initiation) were analyzed (Table 1).
Prevalence
Prior to cART initiation, the prevalence and 95% CI of peripheral neuropathy and SPN were 22.6% (19.0%, 26.4%) and 4.3% (2.7%, 6.4%), respectively.
The treated cohort displayed viral control (i.e. HIV-1 RNA ≤ 400 copies/ml) in 82% (7258 of 8864) of patient visits. Signs of peripheral neuropathy persist despite viral control and improved immune function with initiation of combination ARTs (Fig. 1a-c, Table 2).
Peripheral neuropathy appears to increase over time after initiation of cARTs despite decline in nART use (Fig. 1d).
Symptoms
Most peripheral neuropathy signs occur in the absence of symptoms. Of 2815 patient visits with peripheral neuropathy, 2255 (80.1%) reported a pain level of zero, 2327 (82.7%) reported complete absence of 'pins and needles' sensation, and 2230 (79.2%) reported complete absence of numbness.
Associations with peripheral neuropathy and symptomatic peripheral neuropathy
Evaluation of the associations with peripheral neuropathy and SPN is based on data from 1923 patients (76 with diabetes) with appropriate data, consisting of 7699 patient visits. The median (Q1, Q3) visit per patient was 4 (3, 5).
Associations with peripheral neuropathy
The following variables were associated with a higher odds of peripheral neuropathy in a model simultaneously evaluating all factors: older patient age [OR = 1.89, 95% CI = (1.73-2.07), P < 0.001], baseline CD4 200 or less compared to CD4 at least 501 [OR = 1.39, 95% CI = (1.02-1.90), P = 0.121], current CD4 200 or less compared to CD4 at least 501 [OR = 1.47, 95% CI = (1.16-1.87), P = 0.007], current nART use [OR = 1.40, 95% CI = (1.20-1.63), P < 0.001], taller height [OR = 1.11, 95% CI = (1.05-1.17), P < 0.001], black race compared to white race [OR = 1.25, 95% CI = (1.03-1.51), P = 0.004], and other race compared to white race [OR = 1.96, 95% CI = (1.21-3.19), P = 0.004]. A history of diabetes [OR = 1.57, 95% CI = (0.96-2.59), P = 0.080] and use of a statin drug [OR = 1.17, 95% CI = (0.98-1.41), P = 0.097] also trended towards significance. Viral suppression (HIV-1 RNA ≤ 400 copies/ml) was not associated with peripheral neuropathy [OR = 0.99, 95% CI = (0.84-1.17), P = 0.902] (Fig. 2a).
Associations with symptomatic peripheral neuropathy
The following variables were associated with higher odds of SPN in a model simultaneously evaluating all factors: older patient age [OR = 1.83, 95% CI = (1.60-2.09), P < 0.001], current CD4 200 or less compared to CD4 at least 501 [OR = 1.75, 95% CI = (1.25-2.46), P = 0.011], higher log10 (HIV-1 RNA) at baseline [OR = 1.23, 95% CI = (1.02-1.48), P = 0.030], nART use [OR = 1.60, 95% CI = (1.28-2.00), P < 0.001], history of diabetes [OR = 3.15, 95% CI = (1.74-5.70), P = 0.001], taller height [OR = 1.11, 95% CI = (1.02-1.21), P = 0.014], use of a statin drug [OR = 1.45, 95% CI = (1.15-1.82), P = 0.004], and fewer years since cART initiation [OR = 0.95, 95% CI = (0.91-0.99), P = 0.046]. Viral suppression (HIV-1 RNA ≤ 400 copies/ml) was not associated with SPN [OR = 1.01, 95% CI = (0.76-1.34), P = 0.931] nor was baseline CD4 (P = 0.811) (Fig. 2a).
Associations with recovery after discontinuation of neurotoxic antiretroviral therapy
Patients that had peripheral neuropathy (and SPN) while on nART and later withdrew nART were followed to evaluate recovery. A 54.1% (44.8%, 63.2%) of patients continued to have peripheral neuropathy during all remaining follow-up, whereas 18% (11.7%, 26.0%) of patients had no peripheral neuropathy during all remaining follow-up. 36.8% (24.5%, 50.7%) of patients continued to have SPN during all remaining follow-up, whereas 43.9% (30.7%, 57.6%) of patients had no SPN during all remaining follow-up.
Associations with recovery from peripheral neuropathy
Evaluation of the associations with peripheral neuropathy is based on data from 116 patients (7 with diabetes) with appropriate data, consisting of 338 patient visits. The median (Q1, Q3) visit per patient was 3 (1, 4).
Higher patient age was associated with a lower odds of recovery [OR = 0.33, 95% CI = (0.21, 0.53), P < 0.001]. Viral suppression (HIV-1 RNA ≤ 400 copies/ml) was not associated with peripheral neuropathy [OR = 0.77, 95% CI = (0.32-1.86), P = 0.554] nor was baseline CD4 (P = 0.389) (Fig. 2b).
Associations with recovery from symptomatic peripheral neuropathy
Evaluation of the associations with SPN is based on data from 55 patients (5 with diabetes) with appropriate data, consisting of 162 patient visits. The median (Q1, Q3) visit per patient was 3 (1, 4).
Multivariate models for recovery from SPN were not conducted due to small numbers. Univariate associations are thus reported. Higher patient age was associated with a lower odds of recovery [OR = 0.46, 95% CI = (0.26-0.82), P = 0.006]. HCV was also associated with recovery but the association was not directly estimable using these models. Thirteen of 13 [95% CI = (0.75-1.00)] HCV-positive patient visits had SPN, whereas 74/159 [95% CI = (0.38-0.55)] HCV-negative had SPN. Viral suppression (HIV-1 RNA ≤ 400 copies/ml) was not associated with SPN [OR = 1.53, 95% CI = (0.59-3.96), P = 0.353] nor was baseline CD4 (P = 0.996) (Fig. 2b).
Associations while on neurotoxic antiretroviral therapy
Evaluation of the associations with peripheral neuropathy and SPN are based on data from 573 patients (33 with diabetes) with appropriate data, consisting of 1566 patient visits. The median (Q1, Q3) visit per patient were 2 (1, 4). 27.4% (23.8%, 31.1%) of patients had peripheral neuropathy during all follow-up, whereas 42.1% (38.0%, 46.1%) of patients had no peripheral neuropathy during all remaining follow-up. 9.8% (7.3%, 12.2%) of patients had SPN during all follow-up, whereas 75.2% (71.7%, 78.8%) of patients had no SPN during all remaining follow-up.
Associations with peripheral neuropathy
The following variables were associated with higher odds of peripheral neuropathy while on nART: older patient age [OR = 1.87, 95% CI = (1.56-2.24), P < 0.001], protease inhibitor use [OR = 1.49, 95% CI = (1.15-1.93), P = 0.003], black race [OR = 1.54, 95% CI = (1.07-2.22)] compared to white race, and current CD4 between 351 and 500 compared to current CD4 at least 501. Viral suppression (HIV-1 RNA ≤ 400 copies/ml) was not associated with peripheral neuropathy [OR = 1.08, 95% CI = (0.76-1.53), P = 0.672] nor was baseline CD4 (P = 0.826) (Fig. 2c).
Associations with symptomatic peripheral neuropathy
The following variables were associated with a higher odds of SPN while on nART: older patient age [OR = 1.86, 95% CI = (1.50-2.30), P < 0.001], history of diabetes [OR = 4.59, 95% CI = (1.53-13.83), P = 0.046], taller height [OR = 1.14, 95% CI = (1.01-1.30), P = 0.038], and protease inhibitor use [OR = 1.85, 95% CI = (1.24-2.76), P = 0.003]. Viral suppression (HIV-1 RNA ≤ 400 copies/ml) was not associated with SPN [OR = 0.80, 95% CI = (0.46-1.37), P = 0.402] nor was baseline CD4 (P = 0.898) (Fig. 2c).
| |
| |
| |
|
|
|
