"Triple
Anti-HCV Drug Therapy for Nonresponders to Peginterferon/Ribavirin: Interferon
Gamma (Actimmune) + Ribavirin + Pegasys or Infergen: A Pilot Study"
Reported by Jules Levin
Vijayan Balan and
researchers in the Division of Transplant Medicine at Mayo Clinic in
Scottsdale, AZ, and Larry Blatt from Intermune reported these study results in
poster S914 at DDW May 2005.
There is a need for therapy
for HCV-positive patients who have been previously treated with an
interferon-based therapy who did not achieve a Sustained Viral Response (SVR).
This small pilot study from Balan examines if HCV+ individuals who previously
failed (nonresponders & relapsers) prior treatment with peginterferon plus
ribavirin could respond well to triple therapy:
This is an ongoing,
open-label, single center pilot study. 15 patients are assigned to each study
group on a randomized basis:
Group A: Interferon
alfacon-1 15 mcg once daily + IFN-gamma 1b 100 ug three times per week, plus
RBV weigh-based.
Group B: peginterferon
alpfa-2a 180 ug once weekly + IFN-gamma 100 ug three times weekly + ribavirin.
Ribavirin was weight-based
dosed at 13 mg/kg with a maximum of 1400mg/day. Ribavirin was administered
orally in divided doses, twice daily.
Growth factors such as
erythropoietin (EPO) and G-CSF were used when necessary.
These preliminary results
from a small pilot study find that both triple drug regimens show similar
results after 24 weeks therapy: 2/5 (40%) receiving Pegasys/RBV/IFN-gamma, and
2/6 (33%) receiving Infergen/RBV/IFN-gamma had <50 copies IU/mL, were PCR
negative. (note: The Leevy pilot studies of high dose Infergen plus either RBV
or IFN-gamma showed 35% SVR rates). The tolerability & safety profile
appeared similar & expected results were observed, I don’t think anything
out of the ordinary was reported. These results are based on a small number of
patients & as the authors say the results are good enough to warrant
further study.
The aims of the study are to
examine (1) safety & tolerability of this triple regimen, and the percent
of patients with early viral response (EVR) at week 12 & 24 of triple
therapy. Non-responders to pegIFN/RBV were randomized in this open-label
study to receive the triple therapy or Pegasys+IFN-gamma+ribavirin.
A number of clinical studies
have found that interferon afacon-1, also known as Infergen or Consensus
Interferon, in high doses can achieve an SVR for nonresponders to previous
therapy with peginterferon plus ribavirin. Phase III large studies are now
examing the efficacy of Consensus Interferon. The main question surrounding the
use of daily high dose Consensus is the tolerability, as many researchers feel
the side effects are difficult to tolerate. At this DDW meeting and recent
conferences results from pilot studies presented showed nonresponders to
pegIFN+RBV achieved an SVR with high dose Infergen plus RBV/ At this DDW,
researchers reported Carroll Leevy reported 34% SVR rates in a small pilot
study (n=50) for PegIFN/RBV nonresponders who received Infergen (daily 15 ug)
and IFN Gamma-1b (50 ug 3x/week). You can read the NATAP report of this study:
http://www.natap.org/2005/ddw/ddw_15.htm
RESULTS
(followed by study details)
VIROLOGIC RESULTS
Patients had a significant
reduction in HCV RNA; 3 log+ reductions by week 24--
Mean Baseline Values
(IU/ml):
--Baseline: 5.83
--Week 4: 4.40
--Week 12: 3.61
--Week 24: 2.71
P<0.05
VIROLOGIC
RESPONSE with TRIPLE THERAPY BASED on FIRST 20 PATIENTS
12 weeks
24 weeks
>2 log Neg PCR >2 log Neg PCR
drop <50
IU/ml drop <50 IU/ml
--Overall
9/20
5/20
7/11
4/11
45%
25%
64% 36%
--Pegasys+
6/10
3/10
3/5 2/5
IFNy1b+RBV 60% 30%
60%
40%
--CIFN/gamma/ 4/10 2/10 4/6 2/6
RBV
40%
20%
67% 33%
--The authors concluded the 3-drug therapy with IFNa+IFN-gamma-1b+RBV has
acceptable tolerability.
--based on interim data, the
antiviral activity of 3-drug therapy for non-responders appears promising
as a significant percent of study patients have a >2 log drop in HCV RNA by
week 12.
--further studies in larger
cohorts are warranted.
CURRENT ENROLLMENT
26 patients (target
enrollment is 30), 16 males, 10 females, genotype 1; pegIFN+RBV failures:
--cirrhotic: 12/26 (46%)
--nonresponders: 21/26 (80%)
--relapsers 5/26 (20%)
--mean duration of prior
therapy: 49 weeks
--both 3-drug regimens were
tolerated.
ADVERSE EFFECTS
Common adverse effects were
mild-to-moderate & include: injection site erythema, fatigue, arthralgia,
pyrexia (fever), myalgia, depression, & sleep disturbance. Neutropenia (ANC
<750) occurred in 40% of the first 10 patients treated. 2 SAEa reported to
date (1 death from suicide at week 40 on treatment; 1 hospitalization for
shortness of breath at week 6 of therapy).
Adverse Events Based on
Type of Therapy Based on the First 24 Patients
Infergen/gamma/RBV
Pegasys/RBV/gamma
11 total patients
13 patients
Hematologic
--anemia (<10 g/dl)
4
36%
2 62%
--neutropenia
(<0.750x10(9)/L)
6
55%
6 46%
--thrombocytopenia
(<50x10(9)/L)
4
36%
0 0%
Lab Abnormalities
--hyperuricemia
2
18%
1
8%
--hypogammaglubulinemia 1 9%
0 0
--lipidemia
1 9%
1 8%
--NPN increased
0 0%
1 8%
--prolonged bleeding
(reported by patient)
0 0%
1 8%
Arthralgia
9 82%
11 85%
Back pain
1 9%
2
15%
Muscle cramps
2
18%
1
8%
Myalgia
9 82%
10 77%
Headache
7
64%
9 69%
Dizziness
1
9%
3 23%
Restless leg syndrome 0
0%
1
8%
Depression
5
45%
8 62%
Emotional lability
1
9%
2 15%
Insomnia
8
73%
6
46%
Irritability/anxiety
6
55%
7
54%
Lipido decreased
1
9%
0
0%
Injection Site
Reactions 11 100%
11 85%
Cardiac
--hypertension
1
9%
0 0%
--pedal anemia
3 30%
2 15%
Endocrine disorders
-hypoglycemic
1
9%
0 0%
Flu-like symptoms/signs
--fatigue
10
91%
12 92%
--pain 0
0
1
8%
--pyrexia
10
91%
7 54%
--rigors
10
91%
8 62%
Gastrointestinal
--abnominal pain
3
30%
3 23%
--bleeding hemorrhoids 1 9%
1
8%
--constipation
1
9%
4 31%
--diarrhea
5
45%
6 46%
--dry mouth/
mucous membranes
2
18%
6 46%
--dyspepsia
1 9%
2 15%
--mouth sores
2
18%
5
38%
--nausea/vomiting
4 36%
7 54%
--pharyngitis
0
0%
1
8%
STUDY SUBJECTS
The target population was 30
adult patients with chronic hepatitis C virus infection with genotype 1, who
are viremic, previously treated and failed combination peginterferon-a &
ribavirin. Patients must have previously failed at least 12 weeks of treatment
with pegIFN+RBV (either Pegasys or PegIntron) without significant safety or
tolerability issues.
STUDY DESIGN
A sample size of 15 patients
has at least a 95% chance of including a serious adverse event if the
population incidence is at least 20%. If no serious adverse event were observed
in a sample of 15 patients, we would have 95% confidence that the population
incidence is less than 20%. Likewise, a sample of 15 patients has at least a
95% chance of including a patient with a sustained virologic response if the
population response is at least 20%.
Duration of treatment : 48
weeks with 24 weeks followup.
Medications were not mixed
in the same syringe or injected at the same site. The patient administered the
first dose of the interferons on day 0 at the Clinic under the direction of the
study staff.
Clinical evaluations
included Beck Depression inventory-II & baseline ocular exams for all
patients with diabetes or hypertension
Key inclusion criteria for
patients: hemoglobin >10 gm/dL; WBC >3,000/mm3; neutrophil count
>1,000/mm3; platelets >50,000/mm3; prothrombin time <3 seconds
prolonged compared to control, or equivalent INR; serum creatinine <2.0
mg/dL; hemoglobin A1C <8.5% for diabetic patients (whether on medication
and/or diet controlled); thyroid stimulating hoemone (TSH) within normal limits
(patients requiring medication to maintain TSH levels in the normal range are
eligible if all other inclusion criteria are met); serum hepatitis B surface
antifen (HBsAg) negative; sexcually active patients must practice acceptable
methods (e.g., barrier method) of contraception during the treatment period
& for 6 months after discontinuation of therapy (due to potential for birth
defects from using RBV).
Key Exclusion Cirteria:
patients with evidence of advanced liver disease such as history or presence of
uncontrolled ascites, bleeding varices, and/or encephalopathy; pre-existing
uncontrolled psychiatric condition, especially severe depression, or a history
of severe psychiatric disorder; active substance abuse, such as alcohol (>20
gr/day), i.m., i.v., inhaled or per os. Recreational drugs; if the patient has
a history of substance abuse, to be considered for study they must have
abstained for at least 6 months; patients with clinically significant retinal
abnormalities; patients with ECG showing significant abnormalities; poorly
controlled diabetes; chronic pulmonary disease; uncontrolled immunologically
mediated disease.