| |
Associations between microalbuminuria and animal foods, plant foods, and dietary patterns in the Multiethnic Study of Atherosclerosis - pdf attached
|
| |
| |
Download the PDF here
from Jules-the study: The Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) is a longitudinal, population-based study of 6814 white, African American, Hispanic, and Asian men and women free of clinical cardiovascular disease at baseline and aged 45-84 y. Hypertension contributes to renal vascular damage, excess belly fat (adiposity) contributes to hypertension. Associations with microalbimunuria (protein in urine): less exercise/activity, smoking, hypertension, processed meat, low-fat dairy is better, whole grains and fruits, refined grains is bad.
Am J Clin Nutr 2008;87:1825-36
Jennifer A Nettleton, Lyn M Steffen, Walter Palmas, Gregory L Burke, and David R Jacobs Jr
1 From the Division of Epidemiology and Community Health, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN (JAN, LMS, and DRJ); the Department of Nutrition, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway (DRJ); the Department of Medicine, Columbia University, New York, NY (WP); and the Department of Public Health Sciences, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC (GLB).
"In conclusion, high intake of low-fat dairy foods and a dietary pattern rich in whole grains, fruit, and low-fat dairy food (among other foods) were both associated with lower odds of microalbuminuria and mean ACR [urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratio (ACR; spot urine collection)] in adults free of clinical CVD and diabetes. In contrast, nondairy animal food intake was positively associated with ACR. To the extent that microvascular disease (reflected here by elevated ACR) occurs upstream of overt CVD, these findings point to modifiable dietary factors that may reduce CVD risk. Research in larger studies with prospective dietary measures are need to elucidate the best dietary approach, although it appears a DASH-like (28) dietary pattern excluding meat would be successful."
"In this cross-sectional analysis in a large multiethnic cohort free of clinical CVD and diabetes, a dietary pattern characterized by high consumption of whole grains, fruit, vegetables, and low-fat dairy foods was inversely associated with ACR and the odds of microalbuminuria. Consistent with this, greater intakes of low-fat dairy foods and fruit were each associated with lower ACR, and greater whole-grain intake was marginally associated with lower ACR. By contrast, a dietary pattern characterized by high consumption of beans, tomatoes, refined grains, high-fat dairy foods, and meat food groups and nondairy animal food consumption were each positively associated with ACR......Our findings are similar to those from the Nurse's Health Study, where women with mild renal insufficiency at baseline who consumed more nondairy animal protein experienced a greater decline in kidney function over 11 y of follow-up (32)......Saturated fat, predominantly supplied by animal foods (but amounts negligible in low-fat dairy foods), has previously been associated with greater ACR in persons with diabetes (35) and also with poor endothelial function (62, 63), inflammation (62, 63), and atherosclerosis (64, 65). Furthermore, there is mounting evidence that dairy foods lower the risk of diabetes and other disorders of glucose metabolism that are related to microalbuminuria (29-31). Milk proteins, vitamin D, magnesium, and calcium may partly contribute to these associations (28-31)."
Greater ACR is associated with greater risk of CVD, even in low-risk individuals (19) and may portend development of chronic kidney disease.
"Hypertension contributes to renal vascular damage (17, 66), and excess adiposity is a key antecedent of hypertension. ......renal vascular dysfunction (represented by microalbuminuria) may itself lead to overt macrovascular CVD, or the 2 forms of vascular disease may result from a shared upstream pathway of dysfunction. Lifestyle factors, like diet, may influence CVD by slowing or accelerating processes along this pathway....Microalbuminuria [defined clinically as an albumin-to-creatinine ratio (ACR) of 25-355 mg/g in men or 17-250 mg/g in women] may also reflect widespread endothelial dysfunction (2-6) and atherosclerosis in extrarenal vascular beds.....Participants with microalbuminuria at baseline were older, were more likely to be male, were less educated, were less active, and had greater waist circumferences. participants with microalbuminuria had higher systolic blood pressure, insulin, and glucose and lower eGFR. participants with microalbuminuria ate fewer servings of low-fat dairy foods and more servings of fruit juice and scored lower on the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern. The prevalence of microalbuminuria was 8.6% (7.2%, 11.3%, 9.0%, and 9.4% in whites, Chinese, blacks, and Hispanics, respectively). Only the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern was significantly associated with the odds of microalbuminuria after multivariate adjustment (Table 2, model 1). Compared with participants in the lowest quintile, participants in the 5th quintile had a 39% lower odds of microalbuminuria [odd ratio (OR)"
Jennifer A Nettleton, Lyn M Steffen, Walter Palmas, Gregory L Burke and David R Jacobs, Jr
1 From the Division of Epidemiology and Community Health, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN (JAN, LMS, and DRJ); the Department of Nutrition, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway (DRJ); the Department of Medicine, Columbia University, New York, NY (WP); and the Department of Public Health Sciences, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC (GLB)
2 Supported by training grant T32 HL07779 and contracts N01-HC-95159 through N01-HC-95166 from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and General Clinical Research Center Grant M01-RR00645 from the National Center for Research Resources.
3 Reprints not available. Address correspondence to J Nettleton, Division of Epidemiology & Disease Control, School of Public Health, University of Texas Health Sciences Center, Houston, 1200 Herman Pressler, RAS E-641, Houston, TX 77030. E-mail: jennifer.a.nettleton@uth.tmc.edu.
ABSTRACT
Background: The balance between the intake of animal and the intake of plant foods may influence renal vascular integrity as reflected by urinary albumin excretion.
Objective: We assessed cross-sectional associations between urinary albumin excretion and dietary patterns and intake of plant and animal foods.
Design: At baseline, diet (food-frequency questionnaire) and the urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratio (ACR; spot urine collection) were measured in 5042 participants in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis who were aged 45-84 y and were without clinical cardiovascular disease, diabetes, or macroalbuminuria (sex-adjusted ACR ≥ 250). We derived dietary patterns by principal components analysis. We also summed food groups to characterize plant food intake (fruit, fruit juice, vegetables, nuts, legumes, whole grains, and refined grains), animal food intake (red meat, processed meat, poultry, fish, high-fat dairy, and low-fat dairy), and nondairy animal food intake.
Results: After adjustment for multiple demographic and lifestyle confounders, a dietary pattern characterized by high consumption of whole grains, fruit, vegetables, and low-fat dairy foods was associated with 20% lower ACR across quintiles (P for trend = 0.004). Neither total animal nor total plant food intake was associated with ACR. However, greater low-fat dairy consumption was associated with 13% lower ACR across quartiles (P for trend = 0.03). Total nondairy animal food consumption was associated with 11% higher ACR across quintiles (P for trend = 0.03).
Conclusions: A high intake of low-fat dairy foods and a dietary pattern rich in whole grains, fruit, and low-fat dairy foods were both associated with lower ACR. In contrast, collectively, nondairy animal food intake was positively associated with ACR.
INTRODUCTION
Urinary excretion of albumin is the result of changes in renal glomerular membrane permeability along with alterations in glomerular hydrostatic pressures and may also result from renal vascular injury (1). Microalbuminuria [defined clinically as an albumin-to-creatinine ratio (ACR) of 25-355 mg/g in men or 17-250 mg/g in women] may also reflect widespread endothelial dysfunction (2-6) and atherosclerosis in extrarenal vascular beds (7-13). Although microalbuminuria is particularly common in persons with diabetes and hypertension (14, 15), population-based studies also show that, even in nondiabetic persons, albumin excretion starting in submicroalbuminuric ranges (16-18) is positively associated with cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk, independent of sex, age, hypertension, and other CVD risk factors (19). Thus, renal vascular dysfunction (represented by microalbuminuria) may itself lead to overt macrovascular CVD, or the 2 forms of vascular disease may result from a shared upstream pathway of dysfunction. Lifestyle factors, like diet, may influence CVD by slowing or accelerating processes along this pathway.
Although high total dietary protein intake is hypothesized to contribute to kidney dysfunction and damage in diabetic and healthy adults (20-25), some studies suggest that dietary protein from animal sources may be more detrimental than protein from plant sources in terms of renal health (26). However, dairy food intake has been inversely associated with hypertension, diabetes, and other metabolic disturbances associated with kidney damage (27-31), which suggests that the biological effects of dairy foods may be unique from those of other animal protein sources. Consistent with this hypothesis, a previous study showed that greater nondairy animal protein intake was associated with declining kidney function in women with mild renal insufficiency (32).
Both clinical and observational studies in this area have largely focused on dietary macronutrient intake (particularly total dietary protein) (23-25, 33-36). However, other constituents of animal and plant foods may be equally important, perhaps acting synergistically within the food matrix. The current literature also notably lacks data relating patterns of food consumption to microalbuminuria, even though dietary pattern interventions favorably influence factors associated with microalbuminuria (28, 37).
We investigated associations between dietary intake and ACR in a population-based sample of white, black, Hispanic, and Chinese persons without clinical CVD or diabetes. We hypothesized that nondairy animal foods, and dietary patterns characterized by high nondairy animal food intake, would be positively associated with ACR, whereas plant foods, and dietary patterns characterized by high plant food intake, would be inversely associated with ACR. We further hypothesized that, as the result of differences in saturated fat content (35), intake of low-fat, but not high-fat, dairy foods would be inversely associated with ACR. Finally we hypothesized that dietary associations with ACR would be stronger in those with evidence of kidney dysfunction [estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) <60 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2] than in those with normal kidney function (eGFR ≥ 60 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2).
Subjects
The Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) is a longitudinal, population-based study of 6814 white, African American, Hispanic, and Asian men and women free of clinical cardiovascular disease at baseline and aged 45-84 y. The field centers (and affiliate university) were in Baltimore City and County, MD (Johns Hopkins); Chicago, IL (Northwestern); Forsyth County, NC (Wake Forest); New York, NY (Columbia); Los Angeles County, CA (UCLA); and St Paul, MN (University of Minnesota) (38). Institutional review boards at each participating university approved the protocol, and all participants gave written informed consent. The current baseline cross-sectional investigation includes 5042 men and women, excluding those with diabetes mellitus (39) (n = 922), macroalbuminuria (n = 121), and insufficient or implausible dietary information (40) (n = 618) (numbers not mutually exclusive).
DISCUSSION
In this cross-sectional analysis in a large multiethnic cohort free of clinical CVD and diabetes, a dietary pattern characterized by high consumption of whole grains, fruit, vegetables, and low-fat dairy foods was inversely associated with ACR and the odds of microalbuminuria. Consistent with this, greater intakes of low-fat dairy foods and fruit were each associated with lower ACR, and greater whole-grain intake was marginally associated with lower ACR. By contrast, a dietary pattern characterized by high consumption of beans, tomatoes, refined grains, high-fat dairy foods, and meat food groups and nondairy animal food consumption were each positively associated with ACR.
Greater ACR is associated with greater risk of CVD, even in low-risk individuals (19) and may portend development of chronic kidney disease. Both disease conditions place a heavy burden on public health resources (48, 49). Few studies have evaluated relations between albumin excretion and foods and dietary patterns. Our findings are consistent with the hypothesis that particular aspects of diet may be important intervention targets to prevent elevations in albumin excretion and subsequent development of CVD and kidney disease.
Previous epidemiologic studies of diet and albuminuria in persons with (23-25, 33, 35, 36) and without (28, 34) diabetes largely focused on nutrient intake alone and not on dietary patterns or food intake. To our knowledge, only 2 observational studies have reported associations between albumin excretion and food intake: one in this population (50) and one in a Swedish cohort of persons with type 1 diabetes (51). The latter study reported that young men and women (mean age: 18 y) with type 1 diabetes who had an albumin excretion rate ≥ 15 µg/min consumed less fish than did those with an albumin excretion rate < 15 µg/min (51). In contrast with the results of that study, we found no relation between fish consumption and ACR. Differences in frequency and type of fish consumption, disease states (type 1 diabetes versus nondiabetic), and age (young versus middle-aged) of our samples may partly explain the discrepancy between findings.
A previous analysis of data from MESA showed a weak inverse association between whole grains and ACR (50), which we duplicated here with a slightly different study sample and analytic approach. As previously described, the association was strongest in Hispanic and Chinese participants (50). Although associations noted in the current study were weak, <1% of our sample met current recommendations for whole grain intake (3 servings/d) (52). Greater intake is likely needed to fully evaluate the potential of whole grain intake in terms of albumin excretion. We also noted a moderate inverse association between fruit intake and ACR. Ours is the first study to report such an association. Given the relation between inflammation and albuminuria (53-56), fiber or antioxidant components of fruit may partly contribute to the association we observed (57-59).
Although we noted only weak associations between ACR and whole-grain and fruit intake, the dietary pattern characterized by high consumption of these foods (and also low-fat dairy foods) was inversely associated with ACR and microalbuminuria. This observation underscores the importance of the many dimensions of diet. Although the effects of individual dietary constituents may be small, the overall impact of a diet high in several weakly protective foods may result in greater health benefit than each food alone (18).
The results of studies evaluating associations between different food sources of protein and albumin excretion have been inconsistent, with some suggesting adverse effects of animal protein (especially from red meat) and others showing no difference between animal and plant proteins (26). Partially consistent with the hypothesis that animal protein has an unfavorable impact, we found that nondairy animal food intake was positively associated with ACR, whereas low-fat dairy food intake was inversely associated with ACR. Our findings are similar to those from the Nurse's Health Study, where women with mild renal insufficiency at baseline who consumed more nondairy animal protein experienced a greater decline in kidney function over 11 y of follow-up (32).
Differences in the amino acid and fatty acid composition of nondairy and dairy food groups may partially explain the differing directions of associations. Studies have shown that amino acids metabolized in the splanchnic region have greater renal impact than do those metabolized peripherally, and branched-chain amino acids, common to dairy foods, have lesser renal impact (60, 61). Saturated fat, predominantly supplied by animal foods (but amounts negligible in low-fat dairy foods), has previously been associated with greater ACR in persons with diabetes (35) and also with poor endothelial function (62, 63), inflammation (62, 63), and atherosclerosis (64, 65). Furthermore, there is mounting evidence that dairy foods lower the risk of diabetes and other disorders of glucose metabolism that are related to microalbuminuria (29-31). Milk proteins, vitamin D, magnesium, and calcium may partly contribute to these associations (28-31).
Hypertension contributes to renal vascular damage (17, 66), and excess adiposity is a key antecedent of hypertension. However, adjustment for these potential mediators did not alter associations between ACR and the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern or low-fat dairy. This may be due to incomplete adjustment or, alternatively, may be an indication that these dietary factors intervene along multiple pathways and not exclusively through their known influence on body weight and blood pressure.
We noted interactions between eGFR and the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern and the low-fat dairy and nuts and seeds food groups, where the stronger association with ACR existed in those with (eGFR < 60 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2). However, it is possible that these interactions were the result of chance. Duplication of our findings in other studies is essential before we can conclude that particular dietary aspects are more important in those with early pathology versus normal kidney function.
Several limitations deserve discussion. A single spot urine sample was used to determine microalbuminuria, which may have overestimated the prevalence of microalbuminuria (41, 67), compromising specificity and attenuating odds ratios. We attempted to overcome this limitation by modeling ACR continuously to avoid a presumed cutoff to characterize increased risk (16-18). Our cross-sectional analysis cannot define a temporal sequence between dietary exposures and subsequent development of kidney damage, nor can we rule out residual confounding by inadequately measured or unmeasured variables. For example, regular consumers of low-fat dairy foods likely differ from irregular or nonconsumers in terms of other healthy lifestyle practices that lower microalbuminuria risk. Also important to our low-fat dairy analyses is the fact that low-fat milk intake was queried by the following: "low-fat milk or beverages made with low-fat milk, such as cafŽ latte and cafŽ au lait." Thus, some degree of measurement error exists. Lastly, nonsignificant associations may have been declared significant by chance alone. For example, applying the conservative Bonferroni correction to our food group analyses (P < 0.004) would render most associations nonsignificant.
In conclusion, high intake of low-fat dairy foods and a dietary pattern rich in whole grains, fruit, and low-fat dairy food (among other foods) were both associated with lower odds of microalbuminuria and mean ACR in adults free of clinical CVD and diabetes. In contrast, nondairy animal food intake was positively associated with ACR. To the extent that microvascular disease (reflected here by elevated ACR) occurs upstream of overt CVD, these findings point to modifiable dietary factors that may reduce CVD risk. Research in larger studies with prospective dietary measures are need to elucidate the best dietary approach, although it appears a DASH-like (28) dietary pattern excluding meat would be successful.
RESULTS
Characteristics according to microalbuminuria status
Participants with microalbuminuria at baseline were older, were more likely to be male, were less educated, were less active, and had greater waist circumferences (Table 1). Clinical characteristics also differed; participants with microalbuminuria had higher systolic blood pressure, insulin, and glucose and lower eGFR. With adjustment for energy intake, participants with microalbuminuria ate fewer servings of low-fat dairy foods and more servings of fruit juice and scored lower on the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern. The prevalence of microalbuminuria was 8.6% (7.2%, 11.3%, 9.0%, and 9.4% in whites, Chinese, blacks, and Hispanics, respectively), which is comparable with recent data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys (46, 47).
Dietary patterns and the odds of microalbuminuria
Only the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern was significantly associated with the odds of microalbuminuria after multivariate adjustment (Table 2, model 1). Compared with participants in the lowest quintile, participants in the 5th quintile had a 39% lower odds of microalbuminuria [odd ratio (OR) and 95% CI for Q5 versus Q1: 0.61 (0.42, 0.89), P for trend = 0.02]. This association remained with additional adjustment for the potential mediating variables waist circumference, systolic blood pressure, and hypertension medication use (Table 2, model 2).
Dietary patterns and the urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratio
The sequences of geometric mean ACR across quintiles of the 4 dietary patterns generally supported those for microalbuminuria, with an inverse association between ACR and whole grains and fruit dietary pattern scores and a positive association between ACR and beans, tomatoes, and refined grains dietary pattern scores (Table 3, model 1). Specifically, ACR was 20.3% lower in participants scoring in the highest versus lowest quintile of the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern (P for trend = 0.004). In contrast, ACR was 11.5% greater in participants in the highest versus lowest quintile of the beans, tomatoes, and refined grains dietary pattern (P for trend = 0.04). Further adjustment for potential pathway intermediates did not materially alter the association with the whole grains and fruit dietary pattern but did attenuate the association with the beans, tomatoes, and refined grains pattern to nonsignificance (Table 3, model 2).
Food groups and the odds of microalbuminuria
Of the 13 individual food groups evaluated (Table 4), the strongest association was noted between intake of low-fat dairy foods and odds of microalbuminuria. After adjustment for demographic and lifestyle confounders (model 1), persons in the highest versus lowest quartile of low-fat dairy intake had a 37% lower odds of microalbuminuria [OR (95% CI): 0.63 (0.46, 0.87); P for trend = 0.02]. The association remained statistically significant after adjustment for whole grains and fruit dietary pattern scores [OR (95% CI) for Q5 versus Q1: 0.68 (0.49, 0.95)] or adjustment for the other 12 food groups [OR (95% CI) for Q5 versus Q1: 0.70 (0.50, 0.97)]. Adjustment for pathway intermediates also had little effect on these estimates (Table 4, model 2).
Other food groups were not significantly associated with the odds of microalbuminuria after multivariate adjustment. Distinguishing fried from nonfried fish and white potatoes from other vegetables foods did not change these conclusions (data not shown). Although not statistically significant, there were suggestive inverse associations between microalbuminuria and intake of fruit [OR (95% CI) per serving/d in model 1: 0.94 (0.87, 1.01)] and whole grains [OR (95% CI) per serving/d in model 1: 0.84 (0.69, 1.03)] (Table 3).
Food groups and the urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratio
Associations between food group intake and continuously modeled ACR generally mirrored those for microalbuminuria (Table 5). For each serving/d greater low-fat dairy consumption, the estimated ACR was 2.3% lower (β ± SE per serving/d change: -0.023 ± 0.01, P for trend across quartiles = 0.03, model 1). Similarly, for each serving/d greater fruit consumption, estimated ACR was 1.7% lower (β ± SE per serving/d change: -0.017 ± 0.01, P for trend across quartiles = 0.04, model 1). Although not formally significant, intake of whole grains also showed a moderate inverse association with ACR (P for trend = 0.06). Results were similar when further adjusted for waist circumference, systolic blood pressure, and hypertension medication use (model 2).
Plant, animal, and nondairy animal food groups
Neither the sum intake of all animal foods nor the sum intake of all plant foods was significantly associated with the odds of microalbuminuria (P for trend = 0.49 and 0.20 for total animal food and total plant food, respectively) or ACR modeled continuously (P for trend = 0.90 and 0.20 for total animal food and total plant food, respectively; data not shown).
Although individual nondairy animal foods (red meat, processed meat, poultry, and fish) were not significantly associated with ACR, each serving/d greater intake of the sum of these foods was associated with an estimated 3.9% greater ACR (β ± SE per serving/d difference: 0.039 ± 0.02, P for trend = 0.03, model 1; data not shown). Some of this association appeared to be mediated collectively by waist circumference, systolic blood pressure, and need for hypertension medication (current use) (β ± SE per serving/d difference: 0.028 ± 0.02, P for trend = 0.12, model 2; data not shown).
Interactions between estimated glomerular filtration rate and dietary patterns or food groups
We noted significant interactions between eGFR (< 60 versus ≥ 60 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2) and whole grains and fruit dietary pattern scores (P for interaction < 0.001), nuts and seeds intake (P for interaction = 0.04), and low-fat dairy intake (P for interaction = 0.01). In each case, associations tended to be inverse in both strata, but substantially stronger inverse associations were observed in the smaller group of participants with eGFR < 60 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2 (Table 6; median eGFR = 56.1 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2; 12% with eGFR < 45 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2). There were no statistically significant interactions between eGFR (< 60 or ≥ 60 mL · min-1 · 1.73 m-2) and other studied dietary patterns or food groups.
| |
| |
| |
|
|
|
