| |
Targeted mitochondrial therapy using MitoQ shows equivalent renoprotection to angiotensin converting enzyme inhibition but no combined synergy in diabetes
|
| |
| |
Download the PDF here
Scientific Reports 7, Article number: 15190 (2017)
Abstract
Mitochondrial dysfunction is a pathological mediator of diabetic kidney disease (DKD). Our objective was to test the mitochondrially targeted agent, MitoQ, alone and in combination with first line therapy for DKD. Intervention therapies (i) vehicle (D); (ii) MitoQ (DMitoQ;0.6 mg/kg/day); (iii) Ramipril (DRam;3 mg/kg/day) or (iv) combination (DCoAd) were administered to male diabetic db/db mice for 12 weeks (n = 11-13/group). Non-diabetic (C) db/m mice were followed concurrently. No therapy altered glycaemic control or body weight. By the study end, both monotherapies improved renal function, decreasing glomerular hyperfiltration and albuminuria. All therapies prevented tubulointerstitial collagen deposition, but glomerular mesangial expansion was unaffected. Renal cortical concentrations of ATP, ADP, AMP, cAMP, creatinine phosphate and ATP:AMP ratio were increased by diabetes and mostly decreased with therapy. A higher creatine phosphate:ATP ratio in diabetic kidney cortices, suggested a decrease in ATP consumption. Diabetes elevated glucose 6-phosphate, fructose 6-phosphate and oxidised (NAD+ and NADP+) and reduced (NADH) nicotinamide dinucleotides, which therapy decreased generally. Diabetes increased mitochondrial oxygen consumption (OCR) at complex II-IV. MitoQ further increased OCR but decreased ATP, suggesting mitochondrial uncoupling as its mechanism of action. MitoQ showed renoprotection equivalent to ramipril but no synergistic benefits of combining these agents were shown.
MitoQ is a form of coenzyme Q with a lipophilic cation that selectively facilitates its uptake into the mitochondria where it is postulated to act as an anti-oxidant. MitoQ has demonstrated consistent benefits in disease settings31,32 and is under investigation in CKD Stages 3-5 (NCT02364648). To date, only one study has explored the utility of MitoQ in treating DKD, where daily administration prevented albuminuria in an experimental model of monogenic diabetes of the young (MODY), the Ins2Akita mouse17.
Introduction
There is a rising global incidence of diabetes where progressive diabetic kidney disease (DKD) seen in 25-40% of individuals, is a major factor driving mortality risk1. Inhibitors of the renin-angiotensin system are first line therapies administered upon clinical presentation of DKD2. Although recent figures suggest a stabilisation in the prevalence of DKD3, current therapies only slow progression of the disease and transplantation or dialysis is ultimately required.
With diabetes, it is postulated that tissues with greater metabolic demand are at risk of chronic complications4,5. The kidney cortex has high requirements for aerobic adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthesis via oxidative phosphorylation6, due to processes such as tubular reabsorption of glucose, ions and other metabolites from the urinary filtrate by tubules7,8, and control of glomerular filtration9. As such, the kidneys contain many mitochondria10 and at rest are second only to the heart in oxygen consumption when considered by organ weight6. In diabetes, metabolism11,12, oxygen consumption13,14,15 and glomerular ATP concentrations9 are increased early in disease pathogenesis.
Mitochondrial dysfunction is seen early in the development of experimental DKD13,16 and has been identified as a major contributor to disease progression both in preclinical models13,17,18 and in humans with DKD19,20,21. There is also evidence of mitochondrial dysfunction in other chronic kidney diseases22,23,24. Further, mitochondrial dysfunction can confer susceptibility to chronic kidney disease (CKD)24,25,26. Therapies thought to improve mitochondrial function, including Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10)18,27,28 and SS-31 have beneficial effects on kidney function and fibrosis in experimental models of diabetes29 and obesity30.
MitoQ is a form of coenzyme Q with a lipophilic cation that selectively facilitates its uptake into the mitochondria where it is postulated to act as an anti-oxidant. MitoQ has demonstrated consistent benefits in disease settings31,32 and is under investigation in CKD Stages 3-5 (NCT02364648). To date, only one study has explored the utility of MitoQ in treating DKD, where daily administration prevented albuminuria in an experimental model of monogenic diabetes of the young (MODY), the Ins2Akita mouse17.
Therefore, in the present study, our objective was to compare the renoprotection afforded by MitoQ as a monotherapy and in combination with a first line therapy for DKD, the angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor, ramipril. The ways in which MitoQ and ramipril differed in conferring renoprotection in the diabetic kidney were also investigated.
Results
Body mass and metabolic parameters
At study commencement, all diabetic mice were overweight, with elevated fasting plasma glucose and glycated hemoglobin concentrations, when compared with non-diabetic mice (Table 1). By the study end, fasting plasma glucose (Fig. 1A) insulin (Fig. 1B), and glycated hemoglobin concentrations (Fig. 1C) were all markedly increased by diabetes, but not affected by therapy. However, ramipril treated mice had lower glycated hemoglobin concentrations when compared with MitoQ monotherapy (Fig. 1C). All diabetic mice had glucose intolerance, determined by an oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT), which was not altered by therapy (Fig. 1D,E). All diabetic mice remained overweight at the study end and this was not different among groups (Fig. 1F). Mice with diabetes consumed more food and water and had greater urine output throughout the study and these were unaffected by therapy (Table 1).
Renal function and structure
Diabetic mice had significant albuminuria, shown by elevations in 24 h urinary albumin excretion rate (AER; Fig. 2A) and urinary albumin creatinine ratio (ACR; Fig. 2B) both early (week 4) and later (week 9) during the development of DKD. Early in disease, MitoQ, ramipril and their combination attenuated albuminuria assessed by AER, but not ACR in diabetic mice (Fig. 2A,B, left). Later in disease development, MitoQ attenuated the diabetes-induced increases in AER, but this was not seen with ramipril or combination therapy (Fig. 2A, right). However, both MitoQ or ramipril monotherapy modestly decreased the diabetes-induced increases in ACR later in DKD (Fig. 2B, right).
By the study end, diabetic mice which did not receive therapy had a ~two-fold increase in GFR compared with non-diabetic mice (Fig. 2C, left). This was supported by a decrease in plasma cystatin C with diabetes (Fig. 2C, right). The diabetes-induced increase in GFR was ameliorated by all therapies (Fig. 2C, left). However, plasma cystatin C concentrations in diabetic mice were only increased by MitoQ monotherapy (Fig. 2C, right).
All diabetic mice had renal hypertrophy (Table 1) and mesangial expansion (Fig. 3A; Pictured 3D) by the end of the study, irrespective of the therapeutic intervention. Tubulointerstitial collagen IV deposition was ~three-fold greater in diabetic versus non-diabetic mice, and this was ameliorated by all therapies (Fig. 3B; Pictured 3E). Mice with diabetes also had increased cortical staining of tubulointerstitial collagen using Masson’s Trichrome (Fig. 3C, Pictured 3 F), which was also alleviated by each therapy.
Renal cortical energy storage and substrate metabolites
Energy production including concentrations of adenosine based molecules can mediate glomerular filtration33. Diabetes increased the renal cortical concentrations of the adenosine based energy storage molecules adenosine tri- (ATP; Fig. 4A) and diphosphate (ADP; Fig. 4B) but did not alter the ATP:ADP ratio (ATP:ADP; Fig. 4C). Increases in renal cortical ATP:adenosine monophosphate ratio (ATP:AMP; Fig. 4D), AMP (Fig. 4E) and cyclic AMP (ADP; Fig. 4F) concentrations were also seen with diabetes. Therapeutic intervention decreased both ATP (Fig. 4A) and ADP (Fig. 4B) concentrations as well as the ATP:AMP ratio (Fig. 4D) in diabetic kidney cortices, but did not affect other adenosine based molecules. The renal cortical concentrations of ATP, ADP, cAMP and the ATP:AMP ratio were each significantly related to the glomerular filtration rate (GFR; Fig. 4G) but not albuminuria (AER; coefficients not shown). Overall there were no significant differences among groups in the ratio of creatine phosphate:ATP (C, 1.2 ± 0.4 vs D, 2.5 ± 0.7; P = 0.0 and DMitoQ, 2.3 ± 2.3, DRam, 2.6 ± 1.6, DCoAd, 2.6 ± 1.6).
Central carbon metabolism (CCM) uses a complex series of enzymatic steps to convert nutrients into metabolic precursors for energy production within cells. Analyses of renal cortical central carbon metabolites and amino acid content were performed (See Supplementary Tables S1-S2 for all metabolites). By applying multivariate analysis (Fig. 5A, OPLS-DA scores plot), the metabolites which best predicted the differences between the untreated diabetic group and all other mouse groups were determined. The highest ranked metabolites predicting the differences between the db/db diabetic (D) mouse group and all other mouse groups are shown (Fig. 5B). The variable importance on prediction (VIP) parameter shown in the table (Fig. 5B) ranks the metabolites in order of influence on the multivariate model.
Examination of the specific metabolites ranked by this model showed that the renal cortical concentrations of two glycolytic/gluconeogenic metabolites, glucose 6-phosphate (G6P; Fig. 5C, left) and fructose 6-phosphate (F6P; Fig. 5C, centre), were increased by diabetes and ameliorated with either monotherapy. There was a positive association between renal cortical G6P and F6P concentrations and renal function, defined both by GFR and 24 h urinary AER (Fig. 5G). The tricarboxylic acid (TCA) intermediate citrate-isocitrate (Fig. 5C, right) as well as the electron acceptors, oxidised nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+ and NADP+), were also increased in diabetic kidney cortices (Fig. 5D). Ramipril decreased the renal oxidised isoforms, NAD+ and NADP+, when compared with diabetic mice (Fig. 5D), but MitoQ and combination therapy only trended towards decreasing renal NADP+ (P = 0.082) concentrations. Both oxidised NAD+ and reduced NADH were significantly associated with GFR and AER (Fig. 5G). Renal cortical NADP+ concentrations were related only to GFR and not AER (Fig. 5G). Diabetes increased renal concentrations of cytidine monophosphate (CMP; Fig. 5F, left) and decreased the amino acid glycine (GLY; Fig. 5F, right) and these were related to AER (Fig. 5G), but were unaffected by therapy (Supplementary Data, Tables S1 and S2).
Differences between MitoQ and Ramipril
A multivariate statistical model including treated and untreated diabetic mice was constructed to examine differences between MitoQ and rampril. A representative OPLS-DA scores plot of this model is shown (Fig. 6A), highlighting the relative biochemical similarities and differences among the groups. The major metabolites predicting the differences between MitoQ and ramipril therapy in db/db diabetic mice are shown (Fig. 6B). Diabetes increased the concentrations of dihydroxyacetone phosphate (DHAP; Fig. 6C, left), a precursor for glycerol 3-phosphate and synthesis of other fatty acids and glucose 1-phosphate (G1P; Fig. 6C, right), a molecule produced during glycogen breakdown by glycogenolysis. MitoQ, but not ramipril, therapy attenuated the diabetes-induced increases in renal cortical DHAP and G1P (Fig. 6C). The changes in DHAP and G1P were associated with GFR (Fig. 6D) but not urinary AER (coefficients not shown). The ratio of succinate to fumarate, a surrogate measure of complex II function was increased by diabetes and this was attenuated by MitoQ but not ramapril monotherapy (Fig. 6E).
Evidence from in vitro studies suggests that MitoQ may act as an electron carrier by accepting electrons from complexes I and II and donating these to complex III, to improve mitochondrial and cellular function34,35,36. Hence, mitochondrial function was examined using a maximal electron flow test measuring oxygen consumption rate (OCR) in uncoupled mitochondria during inhibition of various respiratory chain complexes. Here, the flow of electrons from complex I to complex IV is monitored in the presence of FCCP, an uncoupler that carries protons away through the inner membrane without formation of a proton gradient or ATP. Therefore, defects in a specific complex can monitor changes in oxygen consumption when a complex-specific substrate is provided. A representative trace during the electron flow assay shows that diabetes increased oxygen consumption in renal cortical mitochondria when compared with mitochondria from control kidney cortices (Fig. 6F). There were increases in oxygen consumption during the electron flow test in diabetic kidney mitochondria following inhibition of complex I and addition of the complex II substrate, succinate (Fig. 6F and H). Increased oxygen consumption by mitochondria from the diabetic kidney was also seen with inhibition of complex III (Antimycin A) and following donation of electrons directly to complex IV (Ascorbate/TMPD). There were no differences in oxygen consumption in uncoupled mitochondria from diabetic versus control kidney cortices at baseline or following complex I inhibition (Rotenone, Fig. 6G).
MitoQ monotherapy specifically increased the OCR (Fig. 6F) above that seen in mitochondria taken from vehicle treated diabetic mice following inhibition of complex I and addition of the complex II substrate, succinate (Fig. 6G). Increases in OCR with MitoQ monotherapy in mitochondria from diabetic mice were also seen with inhibition of complex III (Fig. 6G), when compared with mitochondria from untreated diabetic mice (Fig. 6E). In the presence of decreased ATP content and unchanged creatine phosphate to ATP ratio, this suggested that MitoQ was acting via mitochondrial uncoupling. MitoQ therapy did not influence OCR during the electron flow test at baseline, following complex I inhibition nor following donation of electrons to complex IV (Fig. 6F,G). Ramipril did not alter oxygen consumption during mitochondrial electron flow testing in diabetic mice (Fig. 6F,G).
Oxidised and reduced coenzyme Q9 and Q10 in the kidney
Since MitoQ is a coenzyme Q derivative with a lipophilic cation to facilitate trafficking to mitochondria, we assessed whether its mechanism of action included effects on mitochondrial concentrations of Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10). CoQ10 plays a central role in trafficking electrons between complexes I, II and III during mitochondrial electron transport. Renal concentrations of oxidised (ubiquinone) and reduced (ubiquinol) CoQ9 and CoQ10 were analysed by HPLC both in cortical homogenates and isolated mitochondria. At study end, total CoQ9 content in cortical tissue was increased in all db/db diabetic mice irrespective of therapeutic intervention (Supplementary Data, Table S3). Total CoQ9 to Q10 ratio was also significantly increased by diabetes and not altered by therapy (Supplementary Data, Table S3). Cortical and mitochondrial ubiquinol content did not change with diabetes nor therapeutic intervention (Supplementary Data, Table S3).
Discussion
In the present study, we demonstrate that once daily oral administration of MitoQ for 12 weeks improved renal function (albuminuria, hyperfiltration) and attenuated tubulointerstitial pathology (collagen) with equivalent efficacy to oral ACE inhibition using ramipril. However there were no synergistic benefits seen with their combined administration. The diabetic kidney had elevations in the cortical concentrations of the metabolites of oxidative phosphorylation and the purine nucleotides ATP, ADP, cyclic AMP and the ratio of ATP:AMP, as well as the phosphate storage molecule and phosphate/ATP buffering molecule, Cre-PO4. All therapeutic interventions attenuated the increases in ATP, ADP and the ATP:AMP ratio. Across all groups, GFR positively correlated with cortical concentrations of the purine nucleotides ATP, ADP, cyclic AMP, the ratio of ATP:AMP and Cre-PO4. Interestingly, there was no discernible relationship between albuminuria by AER and the concentrations of these phosphate fuel storage molecules in kidney cortices. Oxidised (NAD+ and NADP+) and reduced (NADH) nicotinamide dinucleotide concentrations were elevated by diabetes in renal cortices and related to both GFR and AER, irrespective of group. Mechanistically, MitoQ differed from ramipril in that it appeared to act as an uncoupler increasing mitochondrial oxygen consumption and limiting ATP production, creating a futile cycle where excess energetic flux through the respiratory chain was dissipated as heat. MitoQ also attenuated diabetes-induced increases in the glycerol/fatty acid synthesis precursor, DHAP and the breakdown product of glycogenolysis, glucose-1-phosphate. The diabetes-induced mesangial matrix expansion was not attenuated with either mono- or combination therapy.
Previous studies have identified mitochondrial dysfunction13,17,19,21,27,37, including increases in mitochondrial OCR as early pathological events in the kidneys of diabetic rodents11,13. In agreement, we have now shown that mitochondria isolated from kidney cortices of diabetic mice have increased OCR and electron flow specifically at complexes II through to IV of the electron respiratory chain, most likely due to impairment of complex I activity, which has been previously shown in the diabetic kidney13,38. In the present study, there were concomitant increases in ATP, AMP, and cyclic AMP content as well as elevated ATP:AMP ratios in diabetic kidney cortices9,39. Increases in production and/or turnover of renal ATP in our model, agree with a previous study in glomeruli isolated from rodent diabetic kidneys9. However, the higher ratio of creatine phosphate to ATP in our diabetic kidney cortices, indicate that may be the result of a decrease in ATP consumption rather than just over-production, suggesting a breakdown in energy sensing feedback loops including via ADP. Indeed, on one hand ADP content remained higher in diabetic kidney cortices, which would signal for greater ATP production, increased GFR and oxygen delivery. Conversely, however, increases in cellular ATP content could be simultaneously signalling for decreased renal ATP production and for decreased GFR in the diabetic kidney stimulating opposing signalling pathways. The accumulation of ATP, likely as the result of lower consumption of ATP rather than over production by the diabetic kidney, warrants further investigation.
Since mitochondria studied ex vivo from mice treated with MitoQ had greater oxygen consumption in the face of decreases in ATP, one could suggest that in vivo during the course of treatment, MitoQ is acting an uncoupler of the respiratory chain and ATP production which may be realigning ATP and ADP feedback pathways in the kidney, thereby restoring the GFR. Indeed, MitoQ acting in vivo as an uncoupler has been previously described in endothelial cells in vitro40. However, these postulates do not explain the elevation in OCR seen with MitoQ. A more likely explanation is that MitoQ separated the rate of electron transport in the respiratory chain and oxygen consumption from ATP production, which is supported by the increase in OCR in the face of decreased ATP in the present study. Termed as energy dissipating pathways, these processes can increase heat and limit ROS generation. This could also explain why mitochondria from diabetic mice treated with MitoQ showed increased oxygen consumption above that seen in mitochondria from diabetic mice. In addition, these actions of MitoQ in the presence of ramipril, where metabolism was already limited, may explain the lack of synergy between these two agents in improving renal functional markers in this study. However, this requires examination in future studies.
Activation of pathways by diabetes which require increases in the production and accumulation of renal ATP, such as kidney reabsorption of glucose (via sodium dependent glucose transporter, SGLT2), or increases in glycolysis and flux into glucose oxidation could also explain our observed increases in OCR, fuel storage, and cofactor molecules as well as renal hyperfiltration41. Previous in vivo studies have shown that increased ATP-dependent kidney metabolism/transport, in the context of increased mitochondrial oxygen consumption, is a pathway to kidney damage42. In support of this, renoprotection43 is seen following blockade of diabetes-induced increases in renal reabsorption of glucose and sodium using SGLT2 inhibitors, which also decrease renal oxygen consumption44,45 and GFR41,46. Lowering of ATP accumulation in the cortical tubules, could also decrease tubuloglomerular feedback and hence GFR, which is known to be altered by adenine nucleotides. The feedback of high levels of both ATP and ADP in the diabetic kidney may be disrupting adenine modulation of tubuloglomerular feedback. Interestingly, most of the benefits with therapy in the present study were seen in the tubulointersitium, supporting the efficacy of both MitoQ and ramipril in this compartment, by contrast to the lack of effects on glomerular fibrosis.
In the current study, MitoQ further elevated mitochondrial OCR at complex II and III during the electron flow assay, yet attenuated glomerular hyperfiltration. Although GFR is thought to be tightly coupled to tubular oxygen consumption and transport, these data suggest that decreases in renal filtration occurred independently of decreases in cortical oxygen consumption44. Another study has also shown a disconnect between oxygen consumption and hyperfiltration in a model of renal damage (Laustsen). Further, as in the present study, increases in mitochondrial OCR at complex II and III in conjunction with end-organ protection has been shown with MitoQ in previous studies36,47. The specificity of MitoQ effects on OCR at complex II and III is puzzling. MitoQ may have altered the activity of complex II (succinate dehydrogenase) in our model, since diabetes elevated renal succinate:fumarate ratios. Increases in this ratio, which were ameliorated by MitoQ, suggest a dysfunctional complex II in diabetes. Alternatively, it is also feasible that MitoQ limited the flow of substrates from the Kreb’s cycle into OXPHOS since succinate dehydrogenase (complex II) also participates in these reactions. Indeed, this is supported by the decreases in ATP and other adenine nucleotides seen with MitoQ.
We observed increases in the glycolytic intermediates G6P, F6P, DHAP and G1P in diabetic kidney cortices, which is consistent with a previous study in a model of early kidney disease48. This infers a shift towards glucose oxidation including glycolytic pathways in diabetes in order to facilitate cortical demand for ATP production, despite maximal energy production via aerobic fuel production (oxidative phosphorylation) from lactate, FFAs and glutamine already occurring. This increase in glycolysis in the diabetic kidney may be stimulated by the increased accumulation of AMP. This is interesting, given that proximal tubules which constitute a vast proportion of the renal cortex, prefer nutrients other than glucose for ATP generation and have a paucity of rate limiting glycolytic enzymes49,50,51,52,53. However, the build-up of G6P and F6P in the diabetic kidney cortex could also reflect enhanced gluconeogenesis49,52,53 as well as the activation of glycolysis to meet ATP requirements. Whilst this is unresolved in the present study, all therapies decreased G6P and F6P concentrations in the renal cortex, warranting follow up in future studies.
It is also not clear in the present study why the therapies showed disparate effects on AER and ACR both early and later in disease, despite consistent benefits on glomerular filtration. One postulate is that later in this rodent model, insulin insufficiency as a result of secretory defects are greater which could have altered lean muscle mass54 and therefore urinary creatinine excretion. In addition, it is common to use repeated early morning collections to estimate ACR and to reach efficacy that is comparable to a 24 hour AER55. Further, albuminuria does fluctuate in response to decreases in GFR and can spontaneously regress in some diabetic individuals56. Indeed, this is why GFR often provides a more accurate assessment of renal function. Interestingly, GFR rather than albuminuria was more strongly correlated with renal cortical changes in ATP and other adenine based molecules in the present study. However, albuminuria more strongly related to decreases in other metabolic intermediates assessed in this study.
Taken together, these findings suggest that MitoQ confers equivalent renoprotection to a first line therapy for DKD, the angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor, ramipril but their combination does not confer synergistic benefits. Derangements in metabolism were prominent in the diabetic kidney with excess production and/or less consumption of energetic storage molecules such as ATP, cyclic AMP and Cre-PO4 all strongly correlated to glomerular filtration and tubulointerstitial damage. Distinct from ramipril, MitoQ increased mitochondrial uncoupling and electron flow at complex II and III during mitochondrial respiration. The action of MitoQ as an uncoupler may also explain its lack of synergy with ramipril when they were coadministered. These findings should provide the basis for future research to better understand the relationship among delivery of metabolic substrates, mitochondrial function and renoprotection in diabetes and a rationale to further examine mitochondrial targets as treatments for DKD.
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
