| |
The high comorbidity burden of the hepatitis C virus infected population in the United States
|
| |
| |
Download the PDF here
BMC Infectious Diseases 2012 April
Karly S Louie1*, Samantha St Laurent2, Ulla M Forssen3, Linda M Mundy3 and Jeanne M Pimenta1
1 Worldwide Epidemiology, GlaxoSmithKline, 1-3 Ironbridge Road, Stockley Park, Uxbridge UB11 1BT, UK
2 Worldwide Epidemiology, GlaxoSmithKline, Waltham, MA, USA
3 Worldwide Epidemiology, GlaxoSmithKline, 1250 South Collegeville Road, PO Box 5089, Collegeville, PA 19426-0989, USA
"There are multiple reasons why HCV patients may not be treated which include disease stage, patient choice and lack of access to liver specialists [23]. Non-liver specialists may decide that the patient is ineligible for treatment based on a list of contraindications, whereas liver specialists may otherwise safely treat the patient with relative contraindications"
"Most patients were from the northeast region of the United States (63.8%) and 83.1% of patients had HMO (health maintenance organization) or PPO (preferred provider organization) insurance. When comparing HCV infected cases vs. HCV uninfected controls, reported drug use (14.9% vs. 3.2%) and alcohol use (6.5% vs. 0.85%) was much higher among cases. Also, both drug use and alcohol use were 1.3- and 1.7- fold higher among HCV untreated patients versus the treated population........Three notable comorbidities not known to be associated with antiviral treatment or disease were benign neoplasms (24.3%), genitourinary symptoms & ill-defined conditions (14.8%), and viral infections (13.8%).......Among the common extrahepatic manifestations seen among chronic HCV patients (see Table 3; D), we identified rheumatoid symptoms (denoted within connective tissue disease and malaise/fatigue) and psychological disorders (within substance-related mental disorders and depressive disorders) to be the most prevalent in our study population.....benign neoplasms, upper respiratory disease, genitourinary symptoms and ill-defined conditions, and viral infections (which was defined mainly by unspecified viral infections, viral warts, and unspecified herpes simplex). These conditions were about 1.3- to 1.7-fold higher in the HCV-population compared to the HCV uninfected controls.....Several conditions which preclude patients from treatment (see Table 3; B) were also among the top comorbidities; diabetes mellitus without complications (13.8%), and depressive disorders (13.9%), however only those with diabetes mellitus without complications were less likely to be treated during the study period (OR = 0.74, 95% CI: 0.65-0.85).....We did not identify chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in our top list of comorbidities, an antiviral treatment contraindication, however, it ranked only slightly lower than our top 25"
"Treatment rates appear to be declining in the US......it is urgent to understand what barriers may exist that are preventing treatment uptake as the burden of HCV morbidity and mortality increases.......In summary, this study identified a wide range of highly prevalent comorbidities, which may have implications for HCV prognosis, management and treatment success. With over 4 million Americans currently infected with HCV, it is one of the most pressing public health challenges. Effective strategies to manage and control comorbidities among chronic HCV patients may result in increased access to treatment, thereby reducing the future burden of HCV disease and its manifestations......Non-liver specialists may decide that the patient is ineligible for treatment based on a list of contraindications, whereas liver specialists may otherwise safely treat the patient with relative contraindications (i.e. patients with cirrhosis and moderate thrombocytopenia) since most treatment regimens are individualized to achieve maximal sustained virological response....... Up to one-third of our HCV population had a comorbidity that could potentially make them ineligible for antiviral HCV treatment. This indicates that a high proportion of the HCV population could potentially receive effective treatment if their comorbid conditions could be managed......Nearly every HCV patient in our study had at least one comorbidity, and in general, these comorbidities were more common in the overall HCV infected case patients compared to the uninfected controls. In addition, comorbidities covered a wide range of diseases and symptoms affecting a number of body systems. Our findings substantiate that HCV is a systemic disease with many extra-hepatic features which highlight the urgency to treat these extra-hepatic conditions regardless of the liver disease itself."
Abstract
Background
Chronic hepatitis C (HCV) disease can be complicated with comorbid conditions that may impact treatment eligibility and outcomes. The aim of the study was to systematically review comorbidities and symptoms in an HCV infected population, specifically assessing comorbidities associated with HCV anti-viral treatment and disease, as well as comparing comorbidities between an HCV infected and uninfected control population.
Methods
This was a retrospective cohort study within a United States medical claims database among patients with chronic HCV designed to estimate the two-year period prevalence of comorbidities. Patients with two HCV diagnosis codes, 24 months of continuous health insurance coverage, and full medical and pharmacy benefits were included.
Results
Among a chronic HCV cohort of 7411 patients, at least one comorbid condition was seen in almost all patients (> 99%) during the study period. HCV-infected patients reported almost double the number of comorbidities compared to uninfected controls. Of the 25 most common comorbidities, the majority of the comorbidities (n = 22) were known to be associated with either HCV antiviral treatment or disease. The five most frequent comorbidities were liver disease [other] (37.5%), connective tissue disease (37.5%), abdominal pain (36.1%), upper respiratory infections (35.6%), and lower respiratory disease (33.7%). Three notable comorbidities not known to be associated with antiviral treatment or disease were benign neoplasms (24.3%), genitourinary symptoms & ill-defined conditions (14.8%), and viral infections (13.8%).
Conclusions
This US medically insured HCV population is highly comorbid. Effective strategies to manage these comorbidities are necessary to allow wider access to HCV treatment and reduce the future burden of HCV disease and its manifestations.
Background
Hepatitis C virus (HCV) is the etiology of the most common chronic bloodborne infection in the United States (US), affecting at least 4.1 million people, of whom 3.2 million are chronically infected [1]. Chronic infection can lead to progressive development of liver fibrosis to cirrhosis, end-stage liver disease, and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in 5-20% of patients within the first two decades of initial infection [2]. Complications of chronic HCV are projected to increase dramatically over the next few decades [3], placing an ever greater burden on health systems of a disease where the annual health care costs are already estimated at over one billion dollars [4]. Known co-factors for the progression of liver disease include duration of infection, male gender, high-levels of alcohol consumption, hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection, and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. Other data show that metabolic factors such as steatosis, being overweight or obese may also contribute to progression [5]. Several of these factors are comorbid conditions that may also impact HCV treatment eligibility and outcomes. Other conditions that are known contraindications for HCV treatment are severe depressive disorders, hyperthyroidism, hypertension, heart failure, coronary heart disease, diabetes, and pulmonary disease [2].
The current standard-of-care for chronic HCV treatment is combination pegylated-interferon and ribavirin with the addition of boceprevir or teleprevir for genotype 1 patients only [6]. Among patients on pegylated-interferon and ribavirin only, treatment is only efficacious in approximately 55% of treatment-naïve patients [7]. About 75% of treated patients experience one or more side effects requiring discontinuation or dose modification of treatment [8]. Specifically, antiviral treatment may exacerbate certain conditions such as those with anaemia, thrombocytopenia or leukopenia, which can further complicate treatment outcomes by increasing the number and severity of side-effects [9]. Consequently, many patients are excluded from treatment, or have treatment deferred or compromised because of their comorbid conditions.
To maximize the benefit of current and future HCV therapeutic regimens, a greater understanding of the most frequent comorbidities associated with HCV is needed. Successfully managing these comorbidities may lead to increased treatment eligibility and improved outcomes. No studies, to our knowledge have systematically profiled comorbidities among a general HCV population. The objectives of this study were: (1) to systematically estimate the prevalence of the top 25 comorbidities in an HCV population; (2) to compare whether these most common HCV comorbidities differ between receiving antiviral treatment during the study period; and (3) to compare whether these most common HCV comorbidities differ between an HCV infected and uninfected control population.
Results
HCV study population characteristics
A total of 7411 chronic HCV patients were included in this analysis (Table 2). The study population was predominantly male (62.9%) and the median age was 49 years. Almost half of the patients received interferon during the study period (46.8%) and 19.7% had advanced liver disease. Most patients were from the northeast region of the United States (63.8%) and 83.1% of patients had HMO (health maintenance organization) or PPO (preferred provider organization) insurance. When comparing HCV infected cases vs. HCV uninfected controls, reported drug use (14.9% vs. 3.2%) and alcohol use (6.5% vs. 0.85%) was much higher among cases. Also, both drug use and alcohol use were 1.3- and 1.7- fold higher among HCV untreated patients versus the treated population.
Overall frequency of HCV comorbidities
Comorbidities were common in this insured HCV population (Figure 1). Almost all HCV patients (99.4%) reported ≥1 comorbidity and only 41 patients (0.6%) reported none. Fifteen percent reported ≤5 comorbidities, whereas 52% reported 6-15 comorbidities, and 5.5% reported ≥31 conditions. When comparing HCV-infected patients to uninfected controls, HCV-infected patients reported almost double the number of comorbidities (101,219 vs. 53,589, respectively). More uninfected control patients (37.4%) reported ≤5 comorbidities compared to case patients (14.8%). The HCV infected population was more likely to report ≥21 comorbidities than the uninfected, 13.5% vs. 3.7%, respectively.
Top 25 most common comorbidities
Table 3 presents a ranked list of the top 25 most common comorbidities in the overall HCV population, and also presents the frequency of these conditions among the treated and untreated HCV populations. In addition, the association (odds ratios adjusted for age, sex, and advanced liver disease) of the comorbidity between HCV treated and untreated, and between the HCV-infected (all) compared to the uninfected controls are shown. For a number of conditions where the CCS category name is denoted with "other" or was considered not to be fully explanatory, we described the most common conditions that were classified within that comorbidity by ICD-9 codes as a table footnote. Eight symptoms (denoted by category C) and eighteen comorbid conditions were identified among the top 25 list.
Among the top ranked conditions, the majority of the comorbidities were grouped into 7 wider body system classes as follows: diseases of the digestive system (liver diseases, other [rank 1], gastrointestinal disorders, other and unspecified [rank 13], esophageal disorders [rank 16]), disease of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue (connective tissue disease, other [rank 2], back problems, other [rank 7], non-traumatic joint disorders, other [rank 8]), diseases of the respiratory system (upper respiratory infections, other [rank 4], unspecified lower respiratory disease, other [rank 5], upper respiratory disease, other [rank 17]), diseases of the circulatory system (essential hypertension [rank 6], non-specific chest pain [rank 10]), endocrine, nutritional and metabolic diseases and immunity disorders (disorders of lipid metabolism [rank 11] and diabetes mellitus without complication [rank 23]), mental disorders (alcohol and substance-related mental disorders [rank 20] and depressive disorders [rank 22]), and diseases of the nervous systems and sense organs (blindness and vision defects [rank 21], eye disorders, other [rank 25]). Symptoms and signs influencing health status (malaise and fatigue [rank 12] and allergic reactions [rank 18]) were also common in this HCV population.
Other liver diseases (37.5%) was the most common comorbidity (inclusive of symptoms) identified in this HCV population, and of these patients, 70% reported abnormal liver function, 26.7% elevated aminotransaminases, 13.8% abnormal serum enzyme levels, 10.7% ascites, and 9.0% hepatomegaly. In addition, these patients were more likely to have been treated during the study period (odds ratio, OR = 1.34, 95% CI: 1.21-1.47).
Comorbidities associated with HCV antiviral treatment
We note that several conditions associated with antiviral treatment (see Table 3; A) were ranked among the top 25 comorbidities: muscle aches (denoted within connective tissues disease, 34.6% of those treated), sinusitis (within upper respiratory infections, 34.7%), skin irritation (within skin disorders, 28.8% and allergic reactions, which comprised mainly unspecified dermatitis, 17.8%), malaise and fatigue (26.9%), anemia (28.3%), visual disturbances (within blindness and vision defects, 14.8% and eye disorders, other, 14.4%) and depressive disorders (14.1%), however, only those reporting malaise and fatigue (OR = 1.18, 95% CI: 1.07-1.32), anemia deficiency (OR = 1.99, 95% CI: 1.77-2.23) and eye disorders, other (OR = 1.23, 95% CI: 1.08-1.41) were significantly more likely to be treated during the study period. Thyroid disorders, which are contraindicated for treatment, did not rank in the top 25 comorbid conditions (prevalence, 12.5%). However, upper respiratory disease (19.4%; rank 17), was comprised mainly of rhinintis, which is known to be associated with thyroid disorders [16]. Therefore, the high prevalence of rhinitis may suggest the under-diagnosis of thyroid disorders in this HCV population. There was no difference in treatment status for patients with upper respiratory disease, although patients with thyroid disorders were more likely to be treated (OR = 1.60; 95% CI: 1.39-1.85) in our study population (data not shown).
Several conditions which preclude patients from treatment (see Table 3; B) were also among the top comorbidities; diabetes mellitus without complications (13.8%), and depressive disorders (13.9%), however only those with diabetes mellitus without complications were less likely to be treated during the study period (OR = 0.74, 95% CI: 0.65-0.85). Non-specific chest pain (26.5%) could be a symptom of HCV disease or result as an adverse event from pegylated interferon treatment (mainly Pegasys [17]), and it was identified in our ranked list of comorbidities. Although we cannot determine which condition chest pain is associated with, these patients were less likely to be treated (OR = 0.84; 95% CI: 0.76-0.94). We did not identify chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in our top list of comorbidities, an antiviral treatment contraindication, however, it ranked only slightly lower than our top 25 (prevalence, 13%).
Although disorders of lipid metabolism [rank 11] was not defined by HCV management guidelines in Table 1, HCV infection is known to be associated with enhanced lipogenesis, reduced secretion, and ß-oxidation of lipids; therefore, it was not surprising that it ranked in our most frequent list of comorbidities [18].
Comorbidites associated with HCV disease
We also found that several conditions associated with HCV disease ranked among the top 25 comorbidities. Among the symptoms associated with HCV disease (see Table 3; C), joint pain (including back problems (32.5%) and joint disorders (29.3%)) and abdominal pain (36.1%) were identified; and these patients were less likely to be treated. In addition, gastrointestinal disorders (24.4%) comprising mainly of diarrhea, splenomegaly, irritable bowel syndrome and unspecified site of abdominal/pelvic swelling may also result in abdominal pain.
Among the common extrahepatic manifestations seen among chronic HCV patients (see Table 3; D), we identified rheumatoid symptoms (denoted within connective tissue disease and malaise/fatigue) and psychological disorders (within substance-related mental disorders and depressive disorders) to be the most prevalent in our study population.
Among the comorbidities known to be associated with liver disease progression (see Table 3; E), substance-related mental disorders, (associated with drug and alcohol use) and essential hypertension ranked in our top list, and those with substance-related mental disorders were less likely to be treated (OR = 0.70, 95% CI: 0.61-0.80). Although HIV, HBV, obesity did not rank in our list, the prevalence of these comorbidities were 3.2%, 8.4%, and 3.8%, respectively. Approximately 20% of the HCV population had advanced liver disease (cirrhosis and HCC); and these patients are at risk of developing further complications from cirrhosis which occur as a result of portal hypertension and hyperdynamic circulation [19]. This is evidenced by the high ranking of esophageal disorders (particularly esophageal varices) in our ranking of most common comorbidities.
Comorbidities not known to be associated with HCV antiviral treatment or disease
Of the top 25 ranked list of comorbidities, the conditions (n = 3) that were not known to be associated with antiviral treatment or disease, and hence were least expected, were benign neoplasms, upper respiratory disease, genitourinary symptoms and ill-defined conditions, and viral infections (which was defined mainly by unspecified viral infections, viral warts, and unspecified herpes simplex). These conditions were about 1.3- to 1.7-fold higher in the HCV-population compared to the HCV uninfected controls.
Ranking of top 25 comorbidities according to HCV status
The top ranking comorbidities among the overall HCV population were consistently identified in the top 25 comorbidities list of stratified groups of HCV treated, untreated, and controls populations, however with different prevalence and ranking orders (data not shown). There were a few exceptions. Specifically, diabetes mellitus without complication did not rank among the top-ranked list of comorbidities among HCV treated patients, whereas patients with thyroid disorders (13.4%; mainly hypothyroidism) were recorded. Among the HCV untreated patients, eye disorders and allergic reactions were not seen, whereas cardiac dysrhythmias (14.0%) and osteoarthritis (13.5%) ranked. Amongst the uninfected control group, other liver diseases, anemia deficiency, substance-related mental disorders, and depressive disorders were not present in the top 25 list, whereas bone disease and musculoskeletal deformities, other (9.1%), ear and sense organ disorders, other (8.8%), non-malignant breast conditions (8.7%), and cardiac dysrhythmias (8.3%) ranked.
Comorbidities in the HCV population (regardless of treatment status) were more prevalent than in the controls, except for disorders of lipid metabolism (32.2% among controls vs. 25.9% among cases; OR = 0.73; 95% CI: 0.68-0.79). Not surprising, HCV cases with other liver diseases (OR = 19.67; 95% CI: 16.57-23.36) had the highest OR compared to the HCV controls, followed by those with anemia deficiency (OR = 4.57; 95% CI: 4.06-5.14) and depressive disorder (OR = 3.72; 95% CI: 3.25-4.27).
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first study to systematically profile non-selected comorbidities in an HCV population. Nearly every HCV patient in our study had at least one comorbidity, and in general, these comorbidities were more common in the overall HCV infected case patients compared to the uninfected controls. In addition, comorbidities covered a wide range of diseases and symptoms affecting a number of body systems. Our findings substantiate that HCV is a systemic disease with many extra-hepatic features which highlight the urgency to treat these extra-hepatic conditions regardless of the liver disease itself. Individualized anti-viral treatment decisions for HCV infection should weigh the potential risks and benefits of both hepatic and extra-hepatic manifestations to increase the likelihood of treatment success.
Our insured study population reported a 47% current treatment rate, which is comparable to treatment rates (10-51%) in other US medical claims database studies [20-22]. There are multiple reasons why HCV patients may not be treated which include disease stage, patient choice and lack of access to liver specialists [23]. Non-liver specialists may decide that the patient is ineligible for treatment based on a list of contraindications, whereas liver specialists may otherwise safely treat the patient with relative contraindications (i.e. patients with cirrhosis and moderate thrombocytopenia) since most treatment regimens are individualized to achieve maximal sustained virological response. Treatment rates appear to be declining in the US, and it is estimated that from 2002-2030, only 14.5% of liver-related deaths caused by HCV will be prevented [24]; therefore, it is urgent to understand what barriers may exist that are preventing treatment uptake as the burden of HCV morbidity and mortality increases.
Up to one-third of our HCV population had a comorbidity that could potentially make them ineligible for antiviral HCV treatment. This indicates that a high proportion of the HCV population could potentially receive effective treatment if their comorbid conditions could be managed. A recent review has reported that the benefits of treatment can potentially reach a wider HCV population by including targeted groups such as active drug users and persons those with psychiatric illnesses [25]. These patients were able to complete antiviral therapy, achieve a sustained virological response, and did not develop adverse events that would require discontinuation of treatment. However, it was recommended that individualized management of these patients could be integrated within addiction and treatment services [26]. These studies suggest that some comorbidities can be effectively managed, increasing access to HCV treatment with successful outcomes.
Our findings confirm previous studies as we consistently observed the known comorbidities associated with HCV antiviral treatment and disease among our top ranked list, highlighting that our systematic evaluation supports how common these conditions are among the HCV infected population. However, three conditions, benign neoplasms, genitourinary symptoms, and viral infections, were identified in our ranked list and have not been previously reported to be associated with treatment or disease progression. The prevalence of benign neoplasms were mainly of the large bowel and skin (trunk and unspecified sites), which could possibly be explained by metastasis to these sites among HCV patients with HCC but its pathophysiology is unclear and warrants further study [27,15]. In our study, the prevalence of HCC was low, but we cannot exclude the possibility that this may be an underestimation if patients were diagnosed prior to the study period. HCV patients with genitourinary symptoms were mainly of hematuria and proteinuria [28] which could be clinical manifestations of glomerular kidney disease that is known to be associated with cryoglobulinemia and membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis [29]. For the unexpected finding of viral infections, the significance is difficult to interpret given the lack of specificity as almost half the cases were coded as non-specific viral infections.
Our HCV infected population was more likely to report comorbidities than the uninfected controls. This may be explained in part by the higher-risk or unhealthy behavior (e.g., alcohol and drug users) of those infected with HCV, making them more vulnerable to acquire new morbidities than the uninfected population. Indeed, prevalence of alcohol use and drug-use were much higher among the HCV infected compared to the uninfected population (alcohol; 7% vs. < 1%; drug use 15% vs. 3%, respectively). In addition, HCV-infected patients with health insurance may have closer follow-up care and higher rates of screening for other diseases than the uninfected, hence increasing the reporting of conditions. HCV-infected patients may also have more comorbidities because of the illness itself, which may place them at higher risk for other conditions. However, we identified disorders of lipid metabolism to be significantly lower among the HCV population compared to the uninfected population. This finding is not clearly understood since HCV infection is associated with enhanced lipogenesis that may lead to the pathological development of steatosis and metabolic syndromes such as insulin resistance, obesity, and HCC [18].
Our study has several limitations. Firstly, as we used a medical claims database, we did not have liver histology data to confirm stage of disease and thus cannot exclude the possibility of case ascertainment bias as the selection of cases required at least two clinical ICD-9 HCV diagnosis codes for (e.g. patients with more advanced liver disease or on anti-viral treatment would have more clinical visits). Secondly, since data were limited on HCV genotypes (< 1%) and unavailable for racial groups, we were unable to match on these factors in our analyses although HCV disease/treatment efficacy is known to vary by genotype and race [30]. Thirdly, we relied on clinical coding for disease stage so the potential for misclassification of HCV diagnosis and liver disease stage cannot be ruled out. In addition, we cannot exclude the possibility of inconsistent coding or misclassification of comorbidities in our study; for example, COPD, which did not rank in our top 25 list, could have been misclassified under lower respiratory disease which ranked 5. Similarly, cutaneous conditions such as lichen planus and porphyria cutanea tarda which are commonly seen extrahepatic manifestations did not rank in the top 25, however, it is possible that these dermatologic conditions could be misclassified under allergic reactions [rank 18], which was mainly composed of unspecified dermatitis (65.9% of HCV patients with allergic reactions). Furthermore, given the cross-sectional design of this study, we were unable to establish the temporal sequence of events, i.e. whether a comorbidity, such as anemia deficiency, allergic reactions or eye disorders occurred prior to treatment, during treatment, or were treatment side effects. Lastly, patients captured in a medical claims database may be a biased selection of the HCV population as it does not reflect the population who do not have access to healthcare, so estimates of these comorbidities should be extrapolated with caution to the general HCV population. However, our results could be generalized to the privately insured population. According to population-based data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), 61% of those chronically infected with HCV had health insurance and among those insured, half of them had private health insurance [31]. Despite these limitations, our study includes a much broader HCV population than previous studies, which were limited to select populations of US veterans [14,32,33], dialysis patients [34], psychiatric patients [35] and drug users [36]; and represents an insured population that would have access to treatment if comorbidities were able to be managed.
Conclusions
In summary, this study identified a wide range of highly prevalent comorbidities, which may have implications for HCV prognosis, management and treatment success. With over 4 million Americans currently infected with HCV, it is one of the most pressing public health challenges. Effective strategies to manage and control comorbidities among chronic HCV patients may result in increased access to treatment, thereby reducing the future burden of HCV disease and its manifestations.
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
